Spoon Theory is Wrong
Depression is a boat with holes in it. You get one spoon per day to fix the problem.
Nah this ain’t it chief.
Spoon Theory is useful. It’s also why you’ve been stuck.
You know Spoon Theory.
Everyone in this space does. You wake up with a finite number of spoons. Each task costs one. Shower costs one. Phone call costs two. Masking at work all day costs all of them plus the ones you were going to have tomorrow.
It’s a useful framework. It gave a lot of people language for something they’d been failing to explain to the people in their lives for years. I’m not saying it isn’t real.
Here’s my problem with it:
It pathologises the spoon count. It doesn’t ask why yours is lower than it should be.
It says you’re short on spoons because you’re autistic. Bullshit. You’re short on spoons because you’ve been eating dinner with a fork for thirty years and calling yourself inefficient.
The depression isn’t your brain malfunctioning. It’s the correct response to an ongoing resource drain nobody helped you locate. You’ve been managing symptoms while the source runs unchecked in the background.
Fuck this shit honestly.
The Ignored Spoon Drain
Neurotypical depression and neurodivergent depression are different animals and treating them the same is the reason the standard advice never worked on you.
Most self-improvement advice is just neurotypical people describing how their brain works and calling it discipline.
You’re not built for 5am cold plunges and 90 minute blocks of deep work.
Consistency isn’t key.
Engineering your hyperfocus is.
A normal brain is a Toyota Corolla. A reliable all-rounder that will perform ok on almost any road. But neurodivergent brains are F1 Cars. Delicate, finicky, would break down after 1 week of normal roads. But if you give it the care and the track it needs to perform, you have something that smokes the Corolla.
You have a responsibility to yourself to stop taking your V12 Ferrari to the Toyota dealer garage and be your own high performance pit crew.
We are high performance, high maintenance. That’s just how it is.
NT depression: something bad happened, go outside, happy songs to comeback arc. LinkedIn post. A basic oil change. Done.
This doesn’t work for us. Our burnout has a completely different origin.
It’s the compound interest of years of masking, environments built for someone else’s nervous system, social rules you had to reverse-engineer from scratch, jobs that bleed you dry, and the quiet ongoing grief of never being quite sure who you actually are underneath the performance, or understandable lack thereof.
Every single one of those things costs spoons before you’ve even started your day.
The depression is your mind in the wrong environment accumulating interest since you were a kid, sitting in a classroom that was too loud, trying to look like you were ok.
You’re not just running low. The ship is leaking. And there’s holes that nobody helped you find.
The depressed neurodivergent is an F1 car with the wings missing, paint chipped off, and a dead bird clogging the air intake after being daily driven on country roads for years instead of the track where it belongs.
The Death Loop
You know this one.
Low spoons means nothing gets done. Nothing getting done strengthens the lie of a twisted origin story… that you’re lazy, broken, and that the people who wrote you off were right.
That bullshit story costs spoons to carry. Which means less gets done. Which confirms the story harder.
It’s a Death Loop.
The neurotypical fix is “do the thing anyway and the feeling follows.” Make the bed. Take the run. Momentum.
For us this is half right and half catastrophically wrong. When the tank is genuinely empty, pushing through doesn’t build momentum. It blows a gasket. And then you spend three days processing the failure with the obsessive thoroughness only an autistic brain can bring to self-destruction.
We remember everything. Great for special interests. Absolutely brutal for shame and misdirected self analysis.
Shame is the most expensive spoon drain there is and it runs 24 hours a day if you let it.
Find The Leak Before You Count The Spoons
When I’m low for more than three days straight, I stopped asking “what’s wrong with me”.
Now I ask: what in my immediate environment is costing me more than I realised?
Is it a person I’ve been tolerating? A situation I’ve been avoiding dealing with? Sensory conditions I’ve just been enduring rather than fixing because fixing them felt like admitting defeat? A job that requires me to perform a version of myself that doesn’t exist?
Most of the time there’s something specific. Most of the time I have more control over it than I was telling myself I did.
Depression is the smoke alarm not the fire. Waiting for it to stop doesn’t work.
One Spoon. Not Ten.
The worst advice for depressed neurodivergent people is a list of ten things to implement.
You implement two, forget three, feel guilty about the other five, and now you’re more depressed than when you started.
Brilliant. Thanks.
One thing.
Find a small area of life where you can produce one reliable result. Doesn’t matter what it is. Something that creates physical evidence that contradicts the story the your mind is telling. One piece of proof. That’s the whole first phase.
I spent two years being a disaster in most areas and functional in one. No matter how bad things got, I could always lift weights and see real progress that I made happen with hard graft. Evidence of competence.
The linear and undeniable progression put a hard floor on my mental health. A trailing stop-loss.
That one thing kept me from going completely under. Eventually one thing became two. Two became three and then I had something resembling an actual life.
You don’t rebuild the whole house at once. You find the one room that isn’t on fire and you start there.
The People Who Don’t Cost You Spoons
Not therapists. Not well-meaning family doing their best with the wrong map.
The ones who get it from the inside. Other neurodivergent people who’ve been in the dark and came back out. Communities where you don’t have to translate yourself before you can even explain what’s wrong.
People you don’t need to bullshit and who don’t need to bullshit you.
Real Niggas.
Your nervous system knows the difference between being tolerated and being understood. Even if you don’t.
The cost difference between those two things is the difference between slowly refilling and slowly bleeding out.
Even if they’re earnest people, you still pay the price if you’re masking.
Masking defeats the purpose of masking.
The approval you get has no real person to absorb it.
Find one person who gets it. Protect that like it’s your last spoon. Because some days it is.
Stop Romanticising It
This is the type of thing that got me banned out of autism subreddits.
There’s a version of chronic neurodivergent depression that comes with an identity attached. The deep one. The one who sees too much. The one who suffers because they feel everything.
Ok indigo child.
I get it, I do. I am an “empath” but I don’t tell people because that’s not an identity, it’s just that I give a fuck too often.
It’s seductive to romanticise being sensitive because it turns the worst thing happening to you into proof of something special. Like it’s your destiny to be sad.
Tragic. Poetic. The darkness is the evidence.
And on some level your brain doesn’t want to give that up because giving up the depression means giving up the story. And the story is the only thing that made the suffering feel like it meant something.
COPE. This is cope to avoid the real hard question that starts the journey to better things:
Who are you without it?
and
Who could you become without it?
You find out. And you’re better. Lighter. Still weird, still intense, still built different, just not using the darkness as a personality anymore.
Depression isn’t proof you feel deeply. The things you do with your spoons when you finally stop wasting them on shame and masking is the proof.
The Silver Lining
You’re short on spoons because the environment has been pickpocketing you since childhood.
The fix isn’t more willpower, more mindfulness, or copes.
It’s locating the drain. Patching it. Slowly building the count back up by putting your spoons into things that actually return them. The interests, the people, the environments, the work that fits the brain you actually have.
Your brain at full capacity is not a normal brain. You already know this. You’ve felt it. The hyperfocus. The pattern recognition. The way you can go so deep into something you love that time stops existing.
That’s what’s waiting for you underneath the depression.
Depression is loud. It’s been very convincing. It does a very good job at making itself feel permanent.
But it’s just an emotion. It’s transitory. It’s a symptom of suboptimal life. It’s expensive. And now you know where the money’s going.
Cut your losses and invest your spoons in the blue chip dividend stocks life has to offer.
Hyperfocus and driven purpose are your birthright. The reason this genetic mutation exists.
Go get them back.
Get them back in blood if you have to.
If you’re going to meditate, meditate on what it means to allow the spirit of Fuck it we ball to possess and fight for total control of your soul.
Thanks for reading.
Be Good.
God bless.
Get a premium subscription for $1.15 a week.
A dollar fifteen??! For what?!
Deeper, more personal articles and guides from the unfiltered autistic perspective.
Free copy of my $10 book
Access to my file repo (useful email templates for work and whatnot)
7 day free trial below.
After your first payment I’ll send you the repo and book.
You’re paying a dollar fifteen a week to understand how work actually works if you’re autistic and not built for fake social games.
My book is a brutally honest take on autistic career guidance, office politics, and accommodation maxxing tips for mental health and wellbeing.
Yes, I just ranted about my job.
Yes, I’m telling you to read it.
As cool as B2B Sales is, I know I’m supposed to be doing other things too and I want to take you with me.
If any of that hit a nerve, you already know why this exists.
A dollar fifteen a week.
You already waste more than that on things that don’t make your life easier.
Things that don’t actually help.
This might.
:)
Thank you for this. We're all gonna make it brah
You can call it neurodivergent all you want, Brezhnen; Defective is Defective. Failure is Failure. Misery is Misery. There's no making it out.